FERMI QUADRAT PRAIRIE STUDY 2006

Back to Period 3 Student List

GPS LOCATION: N 41 5028.4    W: 8816, 25.5              

STUDENT RESEARCHER: Alexis                 

top Data Table Graphs Comparative Analysis

Map of Fermilab

Back to top


Pictures from prairie


Map of my Quadrat

Map of Fermi Lab


Group Picture


Picture of Beaver


Picture of Bergamont






 

DATA:

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Table of our Fermi Quadrat

PLANT NAME PLANT NAME TOTAL PERCENTAGE DOMINANCE IMPORTANCE VALUE
Indian Grass Indian Grass 14 14 100
Mountain Mint Mountain Mint 1 1 42
Rosinweed Rosinweed 7 7 57
Prairie Cord Grass Prairie Cord Grass 9 9 79
Crab Grass Crab Grass 61 61 429
Yarrow  Yarrow  1 1 26

 

Total Data RAW DATA                      
                     
Native Plant (Prairie Plants) Total Plants Found Total Percentage Found # of Quadrats Found In Density Frequency Dominance Relative Density Relative Frequency Relative Dominance Importance Value  
Big Bluestem 1125 895 28 30.41 0.76 24.19 56.79 21.88 40.41 119.07  
Stiff Goldenrod 26 31 5 0.7 0.14 0.84 1.31 3.91 1.4 6.62  
Compass Plant 42 167 5 1.14 0.14 4.51 2.12 3.91 7.54 13.57  
Indian Grass 162 270 13 4.38 0.35 7.3 8.18 10.16 12.19 30.52  
Switch Grass 72 95 5 1.95 0.14 2.57 3.63 3.91 4.29 11.83  
Rattlesnake Master 1 1 1 0.03 0.03 0.03 0.05 0.78 0.04 0.88  
Prairie Dock 14 97 6 0.38 0.16 2.62 0.71 4.69 4.38 9.77  
Rosinweed 56 42 11 1.51 0.3 1.14 2.83 8.59 1.9 13.32  
Yellow Coneflower 17 11 5 0.46 0.14 0.3 0.86 3.91 0.5 5.26  
Black-eyed Susan 10 40 1 0.27 0.03 1.08 0.51 0.78 1.81 3.09  
Tall Coreopsis 20 16 4 0.54 0.11 0.43 1.01 3.13 0.72 4.86  
Sawtooth Sunflower 45 62 3 1.22 0.08 1.68 2.27 2.34 2.8 7.42  
Wild Bergamot 280 385 21 7.57 0.57 10.4 14.13 16.41 17.38 47.92  
Mountain Mint 9 6 1 0.24 0.03 0.16 0.45 0.78 0.27 1.51  
New England Aster 14 28 5 0.38 0.14 0.76 0.71 3.91 1.26 5.88  
White Prairie Clover 21 30 2 0.57 0.05 0.81 1.06 1.56 1.35 3.98  
Tall Boneset 8 7 3 0.22 0.08 0.19 0.4 2.34 0.32 3.06  
Heath Aster 7 7 2 0.19 0.05 0.19 0.35 1.56 0.32 2.23  
Foxglove Beard Tongue 45 22 5 1.22 0.14 0.59 2.27 3.91 0.99 7.17  
Indian Hemp 7 3 2 0.19 0.05 0.08 0.35 1.56 0.14 2.05  
                     
Invasives (Weeds)                      
                     
Non-Native Plant Total Plants Found Total Percentage Found # of Quadrats Found In Density Frequency Dominance Relative Density Relative Frequency Relative Dominance Importance Value  
Black Raspberry 4 20 2 0.11 0.05 0.54 0 1.94 1.06 3.01  
Daisy Fleabane 29 4 3 0.78 0.08 0.11 0.01 2.91 0.21 3.14  
Wild Carrot 86 18 3 2.32 0.08 0.49 0.04 2.91 0.96 3.91  
Sweet Clovers (tall) 435 280 16 11.76 0.43 7.57 0.18 15.53 14.89 30.6  
Yarrow 48 69 9 1.3 0.24 1.86 0.02 8.74 3.67 12.43  
Tall goldenrod 121 116 15 3.27 0.41 3.14 0.05 14.56 6.17 20.78  
Common Milkweed 2 14 2 0.05 0.05 0.38 0 1.94 0.74 2.69  
Clovers (ground) 7 12 2 0.19 0.05 0.32 0 1.94 0.64 2.58  
Hairy Vetch 14 65 6 0.38 0.16 1.76 0.01 5.83 3.46 9.29  
Hairy Aster 6 7 2 0.16 0.05 0.19 0 1.94 0.37 2.32  
Drummonds Aster 16 11 4 0.43 0.11 0.3 0.01 3.88 0.58 4.47  
Dandelion 13 5 1 0.35 0.03 0.14 0.01 0.97 0.27 1.24  
Unlisted-Round leaf 30 10 1 0.81 0.03 0.27 0.01 0.97 0.53 1.51  
Unlisted-Oval leaf 725 192 8 19.59 0.22 5.19 0.3 7.77 10.21 18.28  
Unlisted-Grasslike 238819 1056 27 6454.57 0.73 28.54 99.36 26.21 56.14 181.71  
Unlisted-Triangular Pointed Leaf 3 2 2 0.08 0.05 0.05 0 1.94 0.11 2.05  
                     
NATIVE PRAIRIE PLANTS                      
SORTED BY DOMINANCE       SORTED BY IMPORTANCE VALUE              
Native Plant (Prairie Plants) Dominance     Native Plant (Prairie Plants) Importance Value            
Big Bluestem 24.19     Big Bluestem 119.07            
Wild Bergamot 10.4     Wild Bergamot 47.92            
Indian Grass 7.3     Indian Grass 30.52            
Compass Plant 4.51     Compass Plant 13.57            
Prairie Dock 2.62     Rosinweed 13.32            
Switch Grass 2.57     Switch Grass 11.83            
Sawtooth Sunflower 1.68     Prairie Dock 9.77            
Rosinweed 1.14     Sawtooth Sunflower 7.42            
Black-eyed Susan 1.08     Foxglove Beard Tongue 7.17            
Stiff Goldenrod 0.84     Stiff Goldenrod 6.62            
White Prairie Clover 0.81     New England Aster 5.88            
New England Aster 0.76     Yellow Coneflower 5.26            
Foxglove Beard Tongue 0.59     Tall Coreopsis 4.86            
Tall Coreopsis 0.43     White Prairie Clover 3.98            
Yellow Coneflower 0.3     Black-eyed Susan 3.09            
Tall Boneset 0.19     Tall Boneset 3.06            
Heath Aster 0.19     Heath Aster 2.23            
Mountain Mint 0.16     Indian Hemp 2.05            
Indian Hemp 0.08     Mountain Mint 1.51            
Rattlesnake Master 0.03     Rattlesnake Master 0.88            
                     
NON-NATIVE (WEEDS)                      
SORTED BY DOMINANCE       SORTED BY IMPORTANCE VALUE              
Non-Native Plant Dominance     Non-Native Plant Importance Value            
Unlisted-Grasslike 28.54     Unlisted-Grasslike 181.71            
Sweet Clovers (tall) 7.57     Sweet Clovers (tall) 30.6            
Unlisted-Oval leaf 5.19     Tall goldenrod 20.78            
Tall goldenrod 3.14     Unlisted-Oval leaf 18.28            
Yarrow 1.86     Yarrow 12.43            
Hairy Vetch 1.76     Hairy Vetch 9.29            
Black Raspberry 0.54     Drummonds Aster 4.47            
Wild Carrot 0.49     Wild Carrot 3.91            
Common Milkweed 0.38     Daisy Fleabane 3.14            
Clovers (ground) 0.32     Black Raspberry 3.01            
Drummonds Aster 0.3     Common Milkweed 2.69            
Unlisted-Round leaf 0.27     Clovers (ground) 2.58            
Hairy Aster 0.19     Hairy Aster 2.32            
Dandelion 0.14     Unlisted-Triangular Pointed Leaf 2.05            
Daisy Fleabane 0.11     Unlisted-Round leaf 1.51            
Unlisted-Triangular Pointed Leaf 0.05     Dandelion 1.24            
                     
ALL PLANTS SORTED BY DOMINANCE     ALL PLANTS SORTED BY IMPORTANCE VALUE            
ALL Plants Dominance     ALL Plants Importance Value            
Unlisted-Grasslike 28.54     Unlisted-Grasslike 181.71            
Big Bluestem 24.19     Big Bluestem 119.07            
Wild Bergamot 10.4     Wild Bergamot 47.92            
Sweet Clovers (tall) 7.57     Sweet Clovers (tall) 30.6            
Indian Grass 7.3     Indian Grass 30.52            
Unlisted-Oval leaf 5.19     Tall goldenrod 20.78            
Compass Plant 4.51     Unlisted-Oval leaf 18.28            
Tall goldenrod 3.14     Compass Plant 13.57            
Prairie Dock 2.62     Rosinweed 13.32            
Switch Grass 2.57     Yarrow 12.43            
Yarrow 1.86     Switch Grass 11.83            
Hairy Vetch 1.76     Prairie Dock 9.77            
Sawtooth Sunflower 1.68     Hairy Vetch 9.29            
Rosinweed 1.14     Sawtooth Sunflower 7.42            
Black-eyed Susan 1.08     Foxglove Beard Tongue 7.17            
Stiff Goldenrod 0.84     Stiff Goldenrod 6.62            
White Prairie Clover 0.81     New England Aster 5.88            
New England Aster 0.76     Yellow Coneflower 5.26            
Foxglove Beard Tongue 0.59     Tall Coreopsis 4.86            
Black Raspberry 0.54     Drummonds Aster 4.47            
Wild Carrot 0.49     White Prairie Clover 3.98            
Tall Coreopsis 0.43     Wild Carrot 3.91            
Common Milkweed 0.38     Daisy Fleabane 3.14            
Clovers (ground) 0.32     Black-eyed Susan 3.09            
Yellow Coneflower 0.3     Tall Boneset 3.06            
Drummonds Aster 0.3     Black Raspberry 3.01            
Unlisted-Round leaf 0.27     Common Milkweed 2.69            
Tall Boneset 0.19     Clovers (ground) 2.58            
Heath Aster 0.19     Hairy Aster 2.32            
Hairy Aster 0.19     Heath Aster 2.23            
Mountain Mint 0.16     Indian Hemp 2.05            
Dandelion 0.14     Unlisted-Triangular Pointed Leaf 2.05            
Daisy Fleabane 0.11     Mountain Mint 1.51            
Indian Hemp 0.08     Unlisted-Round leaf 1.51            
Unlisted-Triangular Pointed Leaf 0.05     Dandelion 1.24            
Rattlesnake Master 0.03     Rattlesnake Master 0.88            

 

Back to top

 


 

GRAPHS OF DOMINANCE AND IMPORTANCE VALUE:

 

Back to top


COMPARATIVE ANALYSIS:

Part 1: Background Information: Our class went to the Fermi Lab. We encountered many grasses and weeds. Fermi was once a farmland, and even before that it was once 100% bare earth and non-native grass. The prairie was planted in 1992 and the prairie grass soon took over the weeds. The importance value tells us how dominant, how frequent and how dense a plant is in the ecosystem, we looked for the importance value at Fermi in our own quadrat. We also looked for dominance, which means the total area covered of a type of plant and we divided it by our total quadrat that we used. We learned that the more diversity there is in a prairie the better the environment is. This is because if there is a disease in the prairie within a species of a plant, it may wipe out all of that plant type, if there is more diversity, then it would be better for the prairie.

 

Part 2: Comparison: Our group’s single quadrat and the team’s totals had different data. Five different types of plants in our groups quadrat was cord grass, mountain mint, rosinweed, yarrow and Indian grass. The team totals for year 2005 and 2006 had much more diversity compared to one quadrat because in plot 17 more were sampled and the data changes. They only showed the top ten yet there was much more diversity than that in the years of 2005 and 2006. The dominance in our prairie quadrat (that was 1x1 meter) was about 32% covered, while the total dominance of 2005 and 2006 was very different because more of 2005 and 2006 got sampled compared to just one quadrat. The importance value in our quadrat has less importance value than the 2005-2006 totals had.

 

Part 3: Prediction: The top three in plants by their dominance in 1992 is unlisted-grasslike, Indian grass and big bluestem. The top three plants found categorized by importance value was unlisted-grasslike, Indian grass and big bluestem. “Unlisted grasslike” we define as a grass that we cannot quite identify but we categorize it as crabgrass because it just looks like grass except taller. Through the ten years of having a prairie, the prairie will grow larger, we know this because ten years ago, the prairie did not have very tall grass and there wasn’t as much diversity as there is now and the grasses now can be from six feet or shorter. As the time moves on, in about ten years, the prairie should have many more diversity and maybe even fewer weeds because of all the weathering and prairie fires. The small roots of a weed will not help the weed continue surviving through an amount of time.

 

Part 4: Reflection:  The trip to Fermi Lab was an enjoying experience. I learned that even trees can be competitive trying to get more sunlight than the other tree. Everything we learned about prairies increased my knowledge about diversity, dominance and importance value. All of our classmates did not know much about prairies before this experience. Even I just thought it was a field covered with tall grasses. Now, we know that there is a larger meaning to this and we have many discoveries found from this trip.

 

 

Back to top

 


COPYRIGHT:

© Copyright 2006, L&T Natural Images and Madison Jr. High, all rights reserved. Contact information: email at lccwik@comcast.net or tcoutts@naperville203.org


ACKNOWLEDGMENT:
This project was created by the 7th grade students of team 7 UPS from Madison Jr. High, Naperville Consolidated Unit School District #203 in Naperville, Illinois with the help of their teacher Mrs. Trudi Coutts along with Technology Lab Director Mrs. Margaret Gilmore. Support for the project came from Principal Ms. Erin Anderson and the other dedicated and cooperative faculty and staff of Madison Jr. High.

 


REFERENCES:
Fermilab Education Department particularly the SIMply Prairie Project. Authors: Bill Fraccaro, Johnson School, Wheaton, IL; Larry Cwik and Pat Franzen, Madison Junior High School, Naperville, IL; and Bernie Jokiel, Gary D, Jewel Middle School, North Aurora, IL.
Created for the NTEP II Fermilab LInC program sponsored by Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory Education Office and Friends of Fermilab, and funded by United States Department of Energy, Illinois State Board of Education, North Central Regional Technology in Education Consortium which is operated by North Central Regional Educational Laboratory (NCREL), and the National Science Foundation.

 


Back to top